Thread:Liu Jen Hao/@comment-25308539-20140909114155

Hey there! I just read over your edits to the girls' pages about how they mirror the members of The Beatles. Definitely an interesting theory, shedding a much deeper look into their personalities, a project I was going to take after finishing my current one. However I don't think it quite belongs on the main pages of each character, let alone under their own heading. Let me try to explain what I think about this, taking an extract you wrote for Mio:

"Much like McCartney, Mio has a penchant for writing sickeningly-sweet and cute lyrics, in spite of being the sole voice of maturity and reason within her band that is obsessed with (unsuccessfully) maintaining order and discipline. And both are unanimously regarded by their respective fans as the most adorable/beautiful/sexy member of their bands."

The 'cutesy lyrics despite being the most mature' part is certainly a good description of her personality, and we can easily find references in the show to point this out. Things like this I would keep as part of the 'Character' heading. However, although the Beatles reference is interesting, maybe it belongs more in the Trivia section, since it's less to do with information we can find directly in the show, rather, it branches out into broader pop culture references. Finally, the last sentence is more subjective than not. I don't think the character bio section is the right place to make statements like that, especially since they move beyond the show itself, into the wider fanbase.

Overall, the parallels really do shed a lot of light on their personalities, but since it's starting to move away from what can be referenced to within their universe, it should probably be moved to trivia. However, the raw, underlying personality descriptions are still gold.

I don't want to just move around pieces that you wrote yourself, so I'd like to get your opinion on this before we make any further changes. 